“I suppose you have seen the papers, Mr. Krugs,” said Peter, once the detective had hurriedly shown them into his office, and managed to find seats enough for all of them. Since few people came to consult with him in entire family groups, and the detective only had two seats for guests, this last part had been managed with some difficulty. In the end it was solved by Mr. Krugs surrendering his seat to Ann, and standing, while Mary was placed on a spare chair borrowed from the neighboring publishing concern that Mr. Krugs shared a building with. It was easy for Mary to see why it had been a spare, as it creaked precariously even under her light frame, with every shift in her body weight she had to worry about whether or not it was going to surrender completely and leave her sitting on the floor.
“I have seen little of anything, Mr. Wells, but the insides of taverns the past few nights,” said Mr. Krugs, motioning to his clothing. “I was asked my a reverend of my acquaintance to examine the conditions of some of these establishments in the neighborhood of the Five Points, where few people care for reading, when they have the knowledge of it.” Mary perked up, and hoped that the detective would go into more detail about what he had found, but he was all business with Peter, who he rightly assumed had no interest in the taverns of the slums.
“Then I ought to warn you, Mr. Krugs, that the papers have had nothing kind to say of Charity and myself for the past two days, and that if you agree to be retained by us, you will likely fall victim to the papers as well.”
“What sort of things have they said?” asked Mr. Krugs, all business. Peter was, however, not entirely comfortable giving specifics, and there was an awkward silence until Ann passed over the article that Peter had first shown them when he was warning them of what was to come. It had been neatly clipped from the paper, something that did not escape the notice of Peter.
“You saved that slanderous piece of trash?” Peter demanded, while Mr. Krugs looked it over carefully.
“I thought it was important,” said Ann, though she looked down, clearly a little ashamed in the face of her brother’s anger.
“Is it true, Mr. Wells,” asked Mr. Krugs, setting down the article and looking straight into Peter’s eyes, much to the shock of everyone, even Ann.
“If it was, I would not have come to you,” said Peter, trying to meet coolness with coolness. “I think I know who has spread these lies about me and my fiance, and I would like to prosecute him, the lawyer will not have it, however, unless we have proof that he has done what I suspect. Ann and Mary seemed under the impression that you were the man for this task.”
“Who do you suspect?” asked Mr. Krugs.
“Charles Hendley,” said Peter, his voice flat.
“The supposed victim of your plot?” asked Mr. Krugs, now looking a little more interested. “He is the son of the merchant family, is he not?”
“He is. I worked for his family until this paper left the hands of a newsboy and reached the eyes of my employer. No firm is willing to face scandal,” added Peter, his voice the most bitter that either of his sisters had heard since he had lost his job. “I value Charity over any employment however,” Peter added, apparently aware that for a moment he had allowed his anger to shine through.
“What will you do if you do discover that Mr. Charles Hendley is the one who gave the newspapers this story?” asked Mr. Krugs.
“I have already said, we will sue him for slander, or I ought to say that Charity will. To say that I am a traitor is hard to deny, as I began to court Charity against his desires. To call Charity a woman of the street however, is not something that can be defended or forgiven.”
“I will see what can be done,” said Mr. Krugs, looking down, and seeming a little embarrassed by Peter’s intensity.
“Thank you very much, Mr. Krugs,” said Charity, smiling warmly at the detective. “Ann seemed very sure of your abilities,” she added, which was enough to make both the detective and the girl blush deeply, and Mary smile behind her hand. Poor Peter looked at everyone with the height of confusion, uncertain why those words had elicited such a strong response. No one was ready to tell him yet however.